Defra consultation muddies the water
- Published on Tuesday, 08 May 2012 11:26
- Posted by Scott Buckler
Government proposals which could allow the withdrawal of water abstraction licences without compensation are extremely concerning, the NFU said today
The development comes as part of a consultation on the Water Act 2003. The NFU believes that Defra has been unclear over what would constitute the ‘serious damage’ that would justify the withdrawal of an abstraction licence, and that not enough emphasis will be placed on exploring all alternative options before withdrawal.
NFU chief environment adviser Dr Diane Mitchell said: “We have considerable concerns with the proposed principles in the current draft and how these may be used to determine ‘serious damage’.
“The approach is complex and the criteria for assessment are un-measurable and open to differing interpretations, while the process for determination of any proposed withdrawal is not transparent and generally very unsatisfactory.
We also have concerns about how this fits with the Human Rights Act, as farmers will effectively be deprived of their property without compensation, and we’ve asked Defra to be mindful of its duty to act in accordance with the Act as it looks to implement this provision.
“Farmers are just as much custodians of the countryside as anyone else, and it is in their interests to ensure there is enough natural resource. That’s why we are very keen to ensure that all alternative options are used before the ‘serious damage’ test is considered or exercised. As drafted, we cannot see how the current process could be deemed to be fair or, more importantly, transparent to our members.”